I really had to sell the idea of Shepherd’s Pie to Hannah. I wasn’t planning to make two completely separate versions, but I immediately recognized the desirability of a dish my children would actually eat, and proposed a “BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger” SP. She was on board once she heard the word “bacon,” although the “BBQ cheeseburger” parts didn’t hurt, either. Josh was upstairs at the time so he only got to taste the final product, not influence its creation.
It was a hit. And if your eating regimen permits, I think the “kid” version is actually highly favored by adults, too. We were all fans at the dinner table that night – although I have to put in a good word for my “grown-up” Butternut Bacon and Mushroom version. You cook the bacon, mushrooms, and meat with red wine, so I felt that it might be more appropriate for more mature palettes. The butternut squash topping was colorful and delicious – and I was free to enjoy the whole thing since I made it dairy free.
It turned out to be quite easy to make two versions, especially bc my sister took care of mashing the potatoes. I think she just scrubbed, forked and microwaved 2 spuds and I didn’t see what else she added during the mashing process. I would suggest butter, buttermilk or Greek yogurt. Whatever she did, though, it was well received.
This fed 3 adults and 2 children with leftovers. I made one square dish (around 8×8 or 9×9) plus a smaller square for the kids.
For the Parents: Butternut Squash, Mushroom & Bacon
2 packs of butternut squash (I used the pre-cut packs from Trader Joe’s – sorry, I can’t remember the oz count. But they only sell one size.)
¾ cup savory cashew cream (I added apple cider vinegar, all-seasoning, salt & pepper, Worcestershire sauce)
½ cup of water
1 spoon of soy butter
Microwave the squash for around 7 minutes. Puree everything and set aside.
For the filling: ¾ c red wine + add’l splash of wine and Worcestishire
The parents might want to eat this, too.
2-3 white potatoes, mashed
2 handfuls of shredded cheese for sprinkling
For the filling: 2 Tbsp. BBQ sauce (I used Sweet Baby Ray’s), add’l splash of BBQ sauce
Mash the potatoes, adding whatever you usually add, e.g. butter, buttermilk, Greek yogurt – set aside.
2 lbs ground meat (I used beef and turkey)
1 8oz packet of mushrooms, sliced
½ an onion, diced (I used the Ninja to dice mine then pureed the squash in the same pitcher. If you like onions you might want to add a spoonful into your squash)
6 slices of bacon, cut into little pieces.
1.5-2 c peas
I split the fillings into 2 pans – one for the wine and one for the BBQ. Saute the onions and mushrooms, season with salt and pepper. Add the bacon and fry it all up! When the bacon is reasonably cooked add the ¾ cup red wine or the 2 Tbsp BBQ sauce. Fry it all up some more. Add the meat and brown it all, seasoning with more salt and pepper. Add in the additional splash of BBQ sauce or the splash of wine/Worcestershire. Stir to combine everything and brown the meat some more. When everything is almost cooked, add in the peas. Finish off the cooking – remember, you’re going to bake this once assembled, so you needn’t cook everything to death right now.
Grease 2 pans – I used small squares. Pile the filling in the bottom. Top with squash or potatoes. For the cheeseburger version, layer it so it’s meat on the bottom, a handful of cheese, the potatoes, and then more cheese. Bake at 350 for 20-30 minutes.